After a quiet month on the posting front, I'm back! I have been working on a large grant proposal in cooperation with several other entomologists, horticulturists, and economists to study the biology, ecology, and management of spotted wing drosophila (SWD) in the eastern United States. I asked for your
help in crafting our objectives for this proposal by completing an online survey during November 2011, and your response was outstanding! We received
274 responses to our online survey and
45 responses from an in-person facilitated stakeholder training in New Jersey (one of our cooperating states). Your responses were used to craft our research objectives, and the proposal was successfully submitted this past Tuesday, January 31.
I am sharing the results of this survey so you can see what were considered high priority SWD research and education areas and how we used this information to craft our objectives.
How did we get the word out?
We distributed links to the survey via email to county extension agents, grower associations, and
regional listserves. I also asked for your input here. All questions were voluntary, and responses were anonymous.
What did we ask?
We collected minimal demographic information (age, sex, state of residence, size of farm, and profession) to help us in interpreting responses. We also asked what small fruit crops were grown on respondents' farms and how they preferred to receive education and outreach information.
Next, we asked respondents to rank 40 possible research and extension activities on a 1 to 10 scale, with 1 least important and 10 most important. We then averaged rankings by the number of responses for and compared rankings across farm size and profession.
Who responded to the survey?
Responses were evenly spread over our target study areas
with 14 respondents either
declining to provide their state of residence or living outside of the eastern
US. Fifty five of the online
respondents were female, while 216 were male and two declined to provide their
gender.
 |
| Number of online survey responses from eastern US regions. |
Only one respondent was
less than 25, while the largest number of responses were from those 45 to 65
years old.
 |
| Age distribution of online survey participants. |
We specifically targeted blueberry and caneberry (blackberry and raspberry) growers, the crops which have experienced the most SWD damage in the eastern US, but respondents also grew a wide range of other crops including: apples, cherries, currents, elderberry, figs, grapes, gooseberries, peaches, persimmons, pears, plums, and strawberries.
What SWD research and extension activities did respondents consider most and least important?
We calculated rankings for research and extension activities for all respondents and for subsets of respondents based on farm size and profession.
All responses
When we grouped all the responses together, the top and bottom five activities were:
Top Five Activities
1. Insecticide efficacy against SWD (rating: 8.94)
2. Insecticide residual activity against SWD (8.91)
3. Insecticide residues & time from harvest to meet maximum residue levels (MRLs) (8.75)
4. Online management guides (8.74)
5. Identification of native natural enemies (8.64)
Bottom Five Activities
36. Association with wild hosts (6.90)
37. Sprayer performance comparisons (6.81)
38. Insecticide implications for export markets (5.43)
39. Off line (hard copy) trap capture reports (5.12)
40. Management in tunnel systems (4.77)
Small sized growers
We received 80 responses from fruit farms smaller than 10 acres, and when these were grouped together, the highest and lowest ranked responses were:
Top Five Activities
1. Online management guides (8.90)
2. Identification of native natural enemies (8.87)
3. Insecticide residues & time from harvest to meet maximum residue levels (MRLs) (8.84)
4. Insecticide effects on natural enemies and/or pollinators (8.47)
5. Insecticide efficacy against SWD (8.70)
Bottom Five Activities
36. Association with wild hosts (7.04)
37. Sprayer performance comparisons (6.86)
38. Off line (hard copy) trap capture reports (5.20)
39. Management in tunnel systems (4.04)
40. Insecticide implications for export markets (4.01)
Medium sized growers
We received 55 responses from fruit farms ranging from 10 to 50 acres, and when these were grouped together, the highest and lowest ranked responses were:
Top Five Activities
1. Insecticide residual activity against SWD (9.07)
2. Insecticide efficacy against SWD (9.04)
3. Insecticide residues & time from harvest to meet maximum residue levels (MRLs) (8.87)
4. Management in open fields (8.80)
5. Online management guides (8.53)
Bottom Five Activities
36. Effects of irrigation & water management on SWD (6.37)
37. Association with wild hosts (6.32)
38. Insecticide implications for export markets (5.02)
39. Off line (hard copy) trap capture reports (4.42)
40. Management in tunnel systems (4.14)
Large sized growers
We received 27 responses from fruit farms ranging from 50 to 100 acres, and when these were grouped together, the highest and lowest ranked responses were:
Top Five Activities
1. Insecticide efficacy against SWD (9.43)
2. Insecticide residual activity against SWD (9.31)
3. Insecticide residues & time from harvest to meet maximum residue levels (MRLs) (9.15)
4. Insecticide effects on natural enemies and/pollinators (9.12)
5. Integration with current integrated pest management and/or brown marmorated stink bug (BMSB) management (9.08)
Bottom Five Activities
36. Effects of irrigation & water management on SWD (6.77)
37. Insecticide implications for export markets (6.67)
38. Association with wild hosts (6.35)
39. Off line (hard copy) trap capture reports (5.71)
40. Management in tunnel systems (4.00)
Very large sized growers
We received 34 responses from fruit farms larger than 100 acres, and when these were grouped together, the highest and lowest ranked responses were:
Top Five Activities
1. Insecticide residual activity against SWD (9.44)
2. Insecticide efficacy against SWD (9.41)
3. Insecticide residues & time from harvest to meet maximum residue levels (MRLs) (8.94)
4. Identification of native natural enemies (8.77)
5. Insecticide effects on natural enemies and/or pollinators (8.71)
Bottom Five Activities
36. Sprayer performance comparisons (6.76)
37. Insecticide implications for export markets (6.71)
38. Effects of irrigation & water management on SWD (6.59)
39. Off line (hard copy) trap capture reports (5.26)
40. Management in tunnel systems (3.94)
Agricultural professionals
We received 59 responses from cooperative extension agents, crop consultants, regulators, university researchers, and graduate students. When these were grouped together, the highest and lowest ranked responses were:
Top Five Activities
1. Insecticide efficacy against SWD (9.27)
2. Insecticide residual activity against SWD (9.21)
3. Management in open fields (9.07)
4. Online management guides (8.72)
5. Host preference (8.57)
Bottom Five Activities
36. Sprayer performance comparisons (6.96)
37. Effects of irrigation & water management on SWD (6.95)
38. Management in tunnel systems (6.67)
39. Insecticide implications for export markets (6.04)
40. Off line (hard copy) trap capture reports (5.36)
General public
Finally, we received 16 responses from master gardeners, homeowners, and other members of the general public. When these were grouped together, the highest and lowest ranked responses were:
Top Five Activities
1. Insecticide effects on natural enemies and/or pollinators (9.50)
2. Biological control (9.27)
3. Identification of native natural enemies (9.13)
4. Cultural/non chemical management tools (9.00)
5. Integration with current integrated pest management (IPM) and/or brown marmorated stink bug (BMSB) management (8.71)
Bottom Five Activities
36. Degree-day models (6.20)
37. Management in tunnel systems (6.15)
38. Sprayer performance comparisons (6.14)
39. Novel pesticide strategies such as chemigation, pesticide combinations, and/or synergists (5.46)
40. Off line (hard copy) trap capture reports (4.67)
How did respondents want to receive research and educational information?
Perhaps not surprisingly,
respondents to the online survey preferred online information delivery tools.
However, this presumably web savvy audience also exhibited a strong preference for
hands on workshops, in person presentations, and extension publications very
highly, suggesting that duel delivery modes for extension and education
information would be desirable.
 |
| Research and extension delivery methods preferred by online survey respondents. |
How will you use these results?
As suggested by delivery method
preferences, hard copy monitoring information ranked low across all groups as
did management strategies focused on high tunnel production. The uniformly low ranking for management
in high tunnel systems suggests that research and extension efforts focused on
these systems are not necessary at this time. Preliminary observations from North Carolina in 2010 and
2011 also suggest that SWD damage may be lower in caneberries grown in tunnels
than in caneberries grown outside.
Management strategies
with the potential for short-term results and implementation ranked highly when
all responses were considered and among commercial fruit growers regardless of
size. These included Insecticide
efficacy, Insecticide residual activity, and Insecticide residues necessary to
meet maximum residue levels. Small growers (0-10 acres) and very large
growers (100 acres or more) also ranked identification of natural enemies in
their top four activities but had little interest in identification of foreign
natural enemies. We did not ask stakeholders to prioritize international
exploration and importation for foreign natural enemies, only identification,
and it is possible that these other activities would be more appealing.
When members of the general public were considered separately from growers and agricultural professionals, potential non target impacts of pesticides (Insecticide effects on natural enemies/pollinators) and non chemical management strategies (Identification of native natural enemies, Biological control, and Cultural/non chemical control) ranked highly. The priority differences between the public and agricultural stakeholders are among the most interesting results of this survey. While our public sample size is small, it is notable that this group was clearly concerned about the potential impacts of increased pesticide use due to SWD.
We used these results to craft our proposal objectives, specifically:
1. Landscape, alternative host, species, and variety risk assessment
2. Optimize adult and larval monitoring tools
3. Best management practices for chemical control tools, including residual activity, rainfall impacts, and residue measurements
4. Demonstration, economic assessment, and adoption of best management practices
We will also use the results of this survey to develop additional proposals and to develop novel and appropriate delivery methods. It will be at least a few months before we hear whether our project is funded, but our group is committed to addressing the unique management challenges posted by SWD in the eastern US. Please don't hesitate to continue to share your thoughts in the comments, at
Twitter, and via
email.